Skip to Main content

  • Crotty's Cheesesteaks

Loaded chili cheese dog with toppings

Crotty's Cheesesteaks

8 Eastchester Road, New Rochelle, NY
‌
‌
Main Menu
Catering

Featured Items

  • The Traditional

    Whiz and Caramelized onion
    $15.50

  • The French Dip

    Side of warm au jus for dipping provolone cheese and caramelized onions
    $16.50

Main Menu

Cheesesteak Sandwiches

  • The Traditional

    Whiz and Caramelized onion
    $15.50

  • The Paulie

    Provolone cheese and caramelized onions with the perfect amount of grilled green and red bell peppers and jalapeños finely chopped
    $16.50

  • The Sicilian

    Provolone cheese, caramelized onions, broccoli rabe, Italian hot peppers, and grilled tomatoes
    $16.50

  • The French Dip

    Side of warm au jus for dipping provolone cheese and caramelized onions
    $16.50

  • The Irishman

    Cheddar cheese, caramelized onions, crispy bacon, mushrooms, and brown gravy
    $16.50

  • The New Yorker

    Caramelized onions, grilled tomatoes, and Cheddar cheese
    $16.50

  • The Rocky Cheesesteak

    Mozzarella cheese, caramelized onions, homemade marinara sauce, cheese, and basil topped with shaved Parmesan cheese
    $16.50

  • The BBQ Pit

    Caramelized onions, signature BBQ sauce, and your choice of cheese
    $15.50

  • The Club

    American cheese, caramelized onions, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo
    $16.50

  • The Steakhouse Cheesesteak

    Gorgonzola, caramelized onions, cheese, & side of warm au jus for dipping
    $16.50

  • The Caesar Cheesesteak

    Served on a bed of fresh romaine, caramelized onions, and imported shredded Parmesan cheese topped with Crotty's creamy Caesar dressing
    $16.50

  • The Vegan Cheesesteaks

    Beyond meat, vegan cheese, and caramelized onions
    $16.50

  • The Custom Cheesesteak

    $13.95

Extreme Cheesesteak Sandwiches

  • The Chili Philly Cheesesteak

    American cheese, caramelized onions, and our homemade chili
    $17.50

  • The Mac & Cheese

    Whiz, Caramelized Onions, Mac & Cheese, and Crispy bacon
    $17.50

  • The Alpha Wolf

    Provolone cheese, caramelized onions, crispy bacon, onion rings, jalapeño peppers, served with a side of of crotty's signature creamy onion vinaigrette
    $17.50

  • The Philly Hangover

    American cheese, caramelized onions, bell peppers, two fried eggs, crispy bacon and tator tots
    $17.50

  • The Wild Buffalo

    Blue cheese, caramelized onions, spicy buffalo sauce, jalapeño peppers, onion rings
    $17.50

NEW and Special Philly's

  • The Big MVP Philly

    Our custom steak blend, caramelized onions, cheese whiz, homemade buffalo chicken fingers, topped with light blue cheese
    $18.50

  • The Chopped Vodka Parm (Limited Time)

    Chopped Crispy Thin Cutlets and Mozzarella Sticks, Caramelized Onions, Bell Peppers, Homemade Vodka Sauce, Melted Mozzarella and Parmesan Cheese, Grilled Pepperoni
    $17.50

  • The Crotty Hottie

    Your Choice of Protein, Caramelized Onions, Chopped Fresh Jalapeños and Pickled Jalapeños, Hot Italian Pepper Relish, Pepper-jack Cheese and Warm Buffalo Sauce
    $17.50

  • The Chopped Chicken Parm Philly

    Chopped Homemade Panko and Italian Seasoned Breaded Cutlets, Chopped Mozzarella Sticks, Smothered in our Homemade Marinara, with Caramelized Onions, Bell Peppers and Melted Mozzarella and Parmesan Cheese
    $17.50

  • The Glizzy Chili Philly

    Boiled Sabrett Hot Dogs, Diced and Grilled with Caramelized Onions, Homemade Chili, Cheddar Cheese, and Warm Ketchup
    $17.50

  • The Chizeee

    Choice of Protein, Caramelized onions, Whiz, Cheddar, and Provalone Cheese
    $17.50

Burgers

  • Single CYO Burger

    Create your own burger just the way you like!
    $7.50

  • Double CYO Burger

    Create your own burger just the way you like!
    $9.50

  • Mushroom Swiss Burger Single Patty

    A Single Philly Patty, with Melted Swiss and Grilled Mushrooms
    $10.50

  • Chili Cheese Burger Single Patty

    Single Steak Patty, American Cheese, with Our Homemade Chili
    $11.50

Breakfast Sandwich All Day

  • Bacon Egg Cheese

    Bacon Egg and American Cheese on a Brioche Roll or Toasted Hoagie. Add Saucy Rascal Hot Sauce at your request.
    $7.00

  • Steak Egg Cheese

    Steak Egg and American Cheese on a Brioche roll or toasted Hoagie. Add Saucy Rascal Hot sauce at your request.
    $9.00

Kids

  • Traditional Cheesesteak Slider (No Onions) & Scoop of French Fries

    $8.50

  • Upside Down Grilled Cheese & Scoop of French Fries

    With a scoop of french fries
    $8.50

  • Kids Homemade Chicken Fingers & Scoop of French Fries

    With a scoop of french fries
    $8.50

Salads

  • Signature Salad

    Mixed greens, tomatoes, dried cranberries, & sunflower seeds topped with Gorgonzola cheese
    $10.95

  • Caesar Salad

    Chopped romaine hearts, shaved Parmesan, and freshly toasted croutons topped with our homemade savory Caesar dressing
    $9.95

  • Crotty's House Salad

    Mixed greens, tomatoes, red onions, and cucumber
    $9.95

Sides

  • Fries

    Large order of crispy & fresh fries!
    $7.00

  • Loaded Curly Fries *LIMITED TIME*

    Crispy Curly Fries with Melted Mozzarella and a Side of Brown Gravy
    $9.50

  • Disco Fries

    Crispy fries, brown gravy, caramelized onions & whiz
    $9.50

  • Small Side of Mac & Cheese

    Crotty's uses 3 different cheeses and a homemade cheese sauce, topped with shaved Parmesan
    $4.95

  • Mac N Cheese Bites *LIMITED TIME*

    Our Homemade Mac and Cheese Bites Served with our Tasty Marinara
    OUT OF STOCK
    $8.95

  • Large Side of Mac & Cheese

    Crotty's uses 3 different cheeses and a homemade cheese sauce, topped with shaved Parmesan
    $12.00

  • Philly Cheese Steak Eggroll

    Two Philly cheese steak eggrolls served with a side cheese sauce
    $9.95

  • Philly Cheese Steak Eggroll Combo

    2 of our Homemade Philly Cheesesteak Eggrolls with a side or Cajun or Regular fries, with a choice of Canned Beverage, Served With a Side of Cheese Dipping Sauce
    $14.95

  • Onion Rings

    Perfectly seasoned large order of onion rings. Comes with crotty's signature creamy onion vinaigrette
    $7.00

  • Fried Pickles

    We love the salty pickle taste with the crunchy breadcrumb coating! Served with a side of ranch dressing
    $9.95

  • Chicken Fingers

    Fried crispy golden-brown & served with buffalo sauce and Honey Mustard
    $9.95

  • Mozzarella Sticks

    Crispy mozzarella sticks served with a side of warm marinara
    $8.95

  • Tater Tots

    Bite sized shredded golden potato balls
    $7.00

Soup

  • Vegetable Soup

    Our Home Made Vegetable Soup Made with Fresh Mixed Veggies served with a Piece of Toasted Buttered Bread
    OUT OF STOCK
    $4.95

Baked Potato

  • Build Your Own Crispy Stuffed Baked Potato

    (Not available during summer months). Our hearty stuffed baked potatoes are made by deep-frying the shell and then stuffing the inside with our butter cream mashed potatoes. Delicious on its own or stuffed with your choice of additions. Always served with
    OUT OF STOCK
    $10.95

Dessert

  • Homemade Cheesecake Bites

    Deep-fried, battered cheesecake balls, covered in powdered sugar, topped with chocolate & caramel syrup
    $9.50

  • Crotty's Signature Egg Cream

    Delicious chocolate beverages made the old-school way!
    $5.50

  • Milkshakes

    These Extra Large 32oz Milkshakes are Decadent, Creamy, & Customizable. Your Choice of either Vanilla or Chocolate Ice Cream. Mix-ins include Oreo, or Chips ahoy . Finished off with Whip Cream on top.
    $9.95

  • GSC Thin mint Cookie Milkshake

    32oz Milkshakes Infused with Girl Scout Thin Mint Cookies, With Chocolate Drizzle, Your Choice of either Vanilla or Chocolate Ice Cream and Topped off with Whip Cream.
    $10.95

Beverages

  • Sport Top Poland Spring Water

    $2.75

  • Bottle Soda

    $3.00

  • Canned Beverage

    $2.00

  • 2 Liter Pepsi

    $5.00

  • 2 Liter Diet Pepsi

    2 Liter Diet Pepsi
    $5.00

Specials

  • Pint-Sized Vegan's Sweet & Spicy Italian Cheesesteak!

    Beyond meat, vegan cheese caramelized onions, fries, hot Italian peppers, mushrooms & sweet teriyaki sauce on a hoagie
    $15.95

  • The Iona Gael Cheesesteak

    American cheese, caramelized onions, choice of protein, bacon, eggs, french fries, and ketchup
    $15.95

  • The RX Superstarwich

    Steak and Chicken Mixed, Provolone cheese, Whiz, caramelized onions, bell peppers, bacon, onion rings, fried pickles, ketchup and buffalo sauce
    $17.95

  • Iona 2 for 20

    OUT OF STOCK
    $20.00

Best Mac N Cheese Shop

  • Bacon Lovers Mac & Cheese

    Elbow Pasta smothered in our Signature Cheese Sauce and topped with Crispy Bacon
    $12.50

  • BBQ Pulled Pork Mac & Cheese

    Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Signature Cheese Sauce and topped with our Slow Cooked BBQ Pulled Pork
    $13.30

  • Buffalo Chicken Mac & Cheese

    Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Signature Buffalo Cheese Sauce Garnished with Blue Cheese
    $13.30

  • Cajun Mac & Cheese

    Elbow Pasta smothered in our Spicy & Cheesy Sauce
    $10.85

  • Cheesesteak Mac & Cheese

    Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Signature Cheese Sauce with Black Angus Beef, Caramelized Onions and Whiz
    $13.65

  • Chicken Teriyaki Mac & Cheese

    Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Signature Cheese Sauce and topped with our tangy Teriyaki Chicken
    $11.55

  • Chili Mac & Cheese

    Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Homemade Cheese Sauce and Loaded up with our Homemade meat Chili
    $15.00

  • Classic Mac & Cheese

    Elbow Pasta smothered in our Signature Cheese Sauce (3 different cheeses!) and topped with Shaved Parmesan Cheese
    $10.50

  • Fresh Veggie Mac & Cheese

    Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Homemade Cheese Sauce and Piled High with our Chef’s selection of Fresh Veggies
    $13.00

  • Parmesan & Garlic Mac & Cheese

    Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Signature Sauce which is blended with Garlic and Parmesan Cheese
    $10.85

  • Pesto Mac & Cheese

    Elbow Pasta in a Creamy Pesto & Cheese Sauce
    OUT OF STOCK
    $11.20

Game-day and party packs

Party Packages for your smaller gatherings 3-12 people

  • The Crotty Hot Box

    1 regular size Traditional, Paulie, and 1 Chopped Chicken Parm Philly cut in 3s, with Cajun Fries and Tater tots
    $50.00

  • The Party Pack

    5 Traditional Cheesesteaks, 5 Paulie Cheesesteaks, Half Tray Of French Fries, Half Tray Of Cesar Salad, a 2 liter of Pepsi and Diet Pepsi!
    $220.00

Vegan Menu

  • Pint-Sized Vegan's Sweet & Spicy Italian Cheesesteak!

    Beyond meat, vegan cheese caramelized onions, fries, hot Italian peppers, mushrooms & sweet teriyaki sauce on a hoagie
    $15.95

  • The Vegan Cheesesteaks

    Beyond meat, vegan cheese, and caramelized onions
    $16.50

Catering

Build Your Own Cheesesteak Kit

  • Build Your Own Cheesesteak Kit

    Enjoy our cheesesteaks at your next party with a build your own cheesesteak kit. Comes with: - 15 hoagies - caramelized onions - your choice of protein - large container of whiz
    $200.00

Platters of Hoagies

Choice of Protein (Black Angus Beef, Grilled Chicken, Pulled Pork and/or Vegan Beyond Meat (V) )Topped with Caramelized Onions and Smothered in Cheese Whiz on a Toasted Garlic Hoagie

  • 12 Traditional Hoagies Platters of Hoagies

    Choice of protein (black angus beef, grilled chicken, pulled pork and/or vegan beyond meat)topped with caramelized onions and smothered in cheese whiz on a toasted garlic hoagie
    $170.00

  • 24 Traditional Hoagies Platters of Hoagies

    Choice of protein (black angus beef, grilled chicken, pulled pork and/or vegan beyond meat)topped with caramelized onions and smothered in cheese whiz on a toasted garlic hoagie
    $340.00

Cheesesteak Sliders

Delicious Mini Cheesesteak Sliders! Black Angus Beef, Caramelized Onions & Whiz on Fluffy Mini Buns. Served by the dozen.

  • Cheesesteak Sliders

    1 dozen (12 sliders) Delicious mini cheesesteak sliders! Crotty's Custom Steak Blend, Caramelized onions & whiz on mini rolls. Served by the dozen
    $70.00

Chicken Parm

  • Chicken Parm Catering

    Homemade cutlets, fried to golden brown, covered with our homemade marinara and melted mozzarella and Parmesan cheese. Half Tray Serves 12-15 and Full Tray serves 24-30
    $70.00+

Salad

  • Serves 12-15) Signature Salad (Half Tray

    Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, dried cranberries & sunflower seeds topped with gorgonzola cheese
    $50.00

  • Full Tray(serves 25-30) Signature Salad

    Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, dried cranberries & sunflower seeds topped with gorgonzola cheese
    $90.00

  • Serves 12-15) Caesar Salad (Half Tray

    Chopped romaine hearts, shaved Parmesan, freshly toasted croutons, topped with our homemade savory Caesar dressing
    $45.00

  • Full Tray(serves 25-30) Caesar Salad

    Chopped romaine hearts, shaved Parmesan, freshly toasted croutons, topped with our homemade savory Caesar dressing
    $80.00

  • Serves 12-15) Cobb Salad (Half Tray

    Shredded iceberg lettuce, chicken, bacon, tomatoes, eggs, red onions, crumbled blue cheese
    $50.00

  • Full Tray(serves 25-30) Cobb Salad

    Shredded iceberg lettuce, chicken, bacon, tomatoes, eggs, red onions, crumbled blue cheese
    $90.00

Catering Sides

  • Mozzarella Sticks Served with Marinara Sauce

    Crispy outer coating with a soft, gooey and cheesey middle. Served with marinara sauce(Half Tray Serves 12-15 full tray 25-30)
    $60.00+

  • Pig in Blanket

    A party favorite, mini hot dogs! Served with sauerkraut and sabrett red onions on the side.(Half Tray Serves 12-15 full tray 25-30)
    $60.00+

  • French Fries Catering

    Crispy & fresh fries! (Half Tray Serves 12-15 full tray 25-30)
    $30.00+

  • Philly Cheesesteaks Eggrolls Catering

    Golden - brown egg roll, stuffed with steak, whiz, caramelized onions.(Half Tray Serves 10-12 full tray 12-24)
    $65.00+

  • Chicken Fingers Catering

    Homemade chicken fingers, fried crispy golden brown & served with buffalo sauce and Honey Mustard.(Half Tray Serves 12-15 full tray 25-30)
    $70.00+

  • Cheesecake Bites Catering

    Homemade deep-fried, battered cheesecake balls, covered in powdered sugar, topped with chocolate and caramel syrup. (Half Tray Serves 12-15 full tray 25-30)
    $65.00+

  • Fried Pickles Catering

    We love the salty pickle taste with the crunchy breadcrumb coating. What's not to love about a fried pickle? We serve ours with a tangy ranch dressing!(Half Tray Serves 12-15 full tray 25-30)
    $60.00+

  • Tator Tots Catering

    Bite-sized shredded golbite-sized shredded golden potato balls!(Half Tray Serves 12-15 full tray 25-30)
    $45.00+

  • Traditional Mac N Cheese Catering

    Crotty's uses 3 different cheeses and a homemade cheese sauce, topped with shaved Parmesan, to take this mac and cheese over the top!(Half Tray Serves 12-15 full tray 25-30)
    $60.00+

  • Creamy Carrot and Celery Slaw

    Half tray (serves 6-8)
    $33.00

  • Penne Vodka Catering

    A tray of penne in our homemade vodka sauce
    $60.00+

Utensils/Napkins

  • Crotty's Cheesesteaks Server

    Would you like help at your party? No problem! We can provide a crotty's server to help with set-up, serving, cleanup and anything else you might need assistance with to make your party a huge success!
    $30.00

  • Wire Basket & 2 Sterno Set-up

    Having a party and wanting to make sure your food stays piping hot? A wire-basket and sterno set-up will keep all of your hot food nice & hot! We recommend one set-up per hot food tray. The set up is your to keep
    $12.00
If you use a credit card, this establishment will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what this establishment pays in fees.

Pig in Blanket

$0.00

A party favorite, mini hot dogs! Served with sauerkraut and sabrett red onions on the side.(Half Tray Serves 12-15 full tray 25-30)

Customize your item

Size

Required
Select 1

Pig in Blanket Options

Optional
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1

Crotty's Cheesesteaks Location

(914) 636-7000
8 Eastchester Road, New Rochelle, NY 10801
View menu
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement